CleanPlate Insight · Public Health

Chicago food inspection failures: August and December compared.

In our historical food-inspection sample, August's failure rate was about 46% higher than December's. Routine Canvass inspections also differed by month. These are pooled comparisons across multiple food-facility types, not a restaurant-only or same-kitchen study.

CleanPlate analysisJune 3, 20264 min read
01 · The pattern

12 months of Chicago kitchens

We bucketed 56,899 Chicago food inspections by the month they happened. The fail rate isn't flat.

December: 14.0% fail rate. August: 20.4%. A 6.4-percentage-point gap. In this historical sample, August's failure rate was about 46% higher than December's.

Monthly fail rate · retrieved historical food-inspection sample

Percentage of inspections resulting in “Fail” outcome, December 2022 – May 2026. Cold months at the right.

Jan
20.6%
Feb
20.4%
Mar
19.6%
Apr
18.9%
May
18.4%
Jun
19.7%
Jul
18.8%
Aug
20.4%
Sep
19.2%
Oct
19.2%
Nov
17.1%
Dec
14.0%

The summer peak is visible, followed by a sharp drop after October.

In this historical sample, August's failure rate was about 46% higher than December's. The comparison does not match the same kitchens.
02 · A narrower comparison

Comparing routine inspections on their own

Chicago does several types of inspections — routine canvass visits, follow-up reinspections, complaint responses, license checks. Different types fail at different rates. So an obvious question is whether the proportions of those inspection types help explain the monthly difference.

We also compared routine Canvass inspections on their own. December's failure rate was still lower than August's in that sample.

Canvass inspections only · monthly fail rate

Restricting to one inspection type removes differences between inspection types from this comparison. The establishments and other conditions can still differ.

Jan
22.0%
Feb
23.0%
Mar
22.0%
Apr
22.0%
May
21.0%
Jun
22.0%
Jul
20.0%
Aug
23.0%
Sep
21.0%
Oct
21.0%
Nov
20.0%
Dec
15.0%

In the Canvass-only sample, August's failure rate was about 23% and December's about 15%. Different establishments can appear in each month; this does not predict the same kitchen's result.

03 · Possible explanations

The cause needs a separate study

Seasonal pest activity is one possible explanation to investigate, alongside differences in establishments, inspection timing and operating conditions. This month-level comparison does not measure those factors or show how much each contributes.

Restricting a comparison to Canvass inspections reduces one source of variation: inspection type. It does not control for facility mix, year, location, inspector or repeated observations of one business. A winter inspection also cannot establish that pests are absent.

Testing a weather or behavior explanation would require additional data and a design that accounts for those differences. The observed monthly pattern alone cannot establish causation or rank an individual establishment's safety.

04 · What this means

How to read inspection records honestly

Read the actual dated findings for the establishment. The month alone does not make a passing result more or less trustworthy, and a historical failure may have been followed by a passing reinspection.

  • Check the inspection date, result, type and violation text together, rather than inferring conditions from the month.
  • Review subsequent inspections for evidence that the official outcome changed; one historical finding does not establish today's conditions.
  • A pest citation is a dated inspector finding in any season. This analysis does not measure which citations remain unresolved.
  • For operators, use the actual findings and official requirements to guide follow-up. This comparison does not predict a location's next result.

Methodology

  • Data source: City of Chicago Food Inspections dataset, accessed via the Chicago Data Portal.
  • Date range: December 2022 – May 2026. Approximately 56,899 inspections in the by-month sample.
  • Fail rate: share of inspections in a given month with results containing “Fail”.
  • Inspection types: Chicago classifies inspections as Canvass, Re-Inspection, Complaint, License, etc. The within-type chart restricts to Canvass — the most common routine inspection — to compare within one type. This does not remove other differences between months.
  • Limitations: the historical sample spans multiple food-facility categories and 3.4 years. Establishments were not matched across months, and the analysis does not adjust for year, geography, facility mix or inspector. It does not establish that weather or pests cause the observed differences. Inspections are snapshots; CleanPlate is independent and not affiliated with CDPH.

See any restaurant's record

Look up a specific Chicago restaurant's full inspection history — across seasons. Free, no signup.

Search a restaurant

About CleanPlate: An independent project analyzing Chicago's public food inspection data. We are not affiliated with the City of Chicago, the Chicago Department of Public Health, or any government agency. The CleanPlate Score is a proprietary metric and is not an official rating. Read more about our methodology.